Imperium

San Francisco County

Meeting on Settlements, Affordable Housing and Zoning Approvals

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on March 5, 2019, addressing a wide range of issues, with an emphasis on financial settlements, housing, and zoning. The board approved multiple settlements for lawsuits and unlitigated claims against the city, totaling significant financial payouts. The board also focused heavily on measures to address affordable housing shortages, with loan agreements, and resolutions related to financing affordable housing projects. Moreover, a substantial portion of the meeting addressed zoning and planning issues, with the board approving ordinances related to landmark designations, zoning map changes, commercial storefront regulations, and special use districts. Several new business ordinances and resolutions were adopted, reflecting the city's commitment to various community services and initiatives, including those aimed at homelessness, domestic violence prevention, and economic development. Noteworthy testimonies were delivered, public commentary, in which concerns regarding presidential actions and family planning were raised. Multiple committee referrals were made, setting the stage for future discussions on issues such as campaign finance reform, Muni performance metrics, and juvenile probation policies.

Search for Specific Moments

Consent Agenda

Approved settlements for several lawsuits and claims against the City and County of San Francisco.

The Board approved a series of settlements under the recommendations of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee. These included settlements for lawsuits filed by Small Property Owners of San Francisco Institute ($110,000), Susan Garduno ($105,000), Winfield International, Inc. ($500,000 to be paid to the city), N.C., a Minor ($45,000), and Rocio Guarniz Palacios ($50,000), as well as an unlitigated claim filed by Sambou Makalou ($124,523.97). Additionally, under the recommendations of the Land Use and Transportation Committee, the Board approved ordinances related to Planning Code amendments for landmark designations, zoning map changes, and commemorative plaques. These included the designation of Theodore Roosevelt Middle School and Sunshine School as landmarks, rezoning a portion of Valencia Street, and waiving fees for a commemorative plaque for Salina Lam. An ordinance related to conversion of Medical Cannabis Dispensary uses to Cannabis Retail Uses was also approved. Finally, the Board approved an ordinance amending the Police Code to rescind authorization for the Police Department to be a member of the National Rifle Association.

Unfinished Business

Established the SoMa West Community Benefit District with amendments to supporting documents.

The Board discussed and approved the establishment of the SoMa West Community Benefit District. Chris Corgas and Jon Givner were present to answer questions. Amendments to the supporting documents, specifically the Management Plan and Engineer’s Report, were accepted without objection. These amendments included defining board of directors composition that meets both City and State law and insures representation from non-profit housing entities, cultural organizations/districts, education institutions, small business owners, residents (both property owners and bib-property owners). and indicating non-profit owned parcels do not benefit from the marketing and communications service area and the 7.56% ascribed to this area were deducted from their assessment payment, the amount was taken from the budget section to ensure added costs were not put on other property owners, the Steering Committee agreed to a 40% reduction for non-profit housing parcels, and the Community Benefit District will fundraise the 40% reductions for these parcels. The final vote was unanimous.

Unfinished Business

Approved an ordinance prohibiting police officers from questioning youth in custody without meeting certain conditions.

The Board approved an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to prohibit police officers from questioning persons 17 years of age or younger, in custody, unless certain conditions are met. The ordinance provides for legal representation of the youth and mandates that responsible adults be given access to youth while police officers question youth. The vote was unanimous.

New Business

Approved a grant for leveraging collaboration to end domestic violence, with Supervisor Walton excused from voting due to a conflict of interest.

The Board approved an ordinance retroactively authorizing the Department on the Status of Women to accept and expend a grant from the Blue Shield of California Foundation for Leveraging Collaboration to End Domestic Violence Program. The ordinance also amended the Annual Salary Ordinance to provide for the addition of one grant-funded part-time Junior Administrative Analyst position. Ben Rosenfield and Dr. Emily Murase were present to answer questions. Supervisor Walton was excused from voting on this item due to a possible conflict of interest.

New Business

Authorized the Treasurer to borrow funds for a short-term loan program for federal employees during a government shutdown.

The Board approved two ordinances related to a short-term loan program for federal employees in the event of a government shutdown. One ordinance authorized the Treasurer to secure a line of credit or partner with financial institutions for the program. The other ordinance appropriated funds to the Treasurer’s and Tax Collector’s Office to administer individual loans for eligible Federal employees impacted by a future shutdown. Supervisor Safai requested to be added as a co-sponsor to both ordinances.

New Business

Approved lease agreements for food and beverage concessions at Terminal 1 of the San Francisco International Airport.

The Board approved three resolutions related to lease agreements for food and beverage concessions at Terminal 1 of the San Francisco International Airport. These included agreements with Host International, Inc., Lady Luck Gourmet, LLC, and SF Foodways, LLC. All resolutions were adopted unanimously.

New Business

Approved a grant and agreement amendment for small business technical assistance and behavioral health services.

The Board approved a resolution retroactively authorizing the Office of Economic and Workforce Development to accept and expend a grant from the Humboldt State University Program Foundation to expand the capacity of the San Francisco Small Business Development Center. Additionally, the Board approved a resolution approving an amendment to the agreement between Westside Community Mental Health Center, Inc. and the Department of Public Health for behavioral health services.

New Business

Approved loan agreements and revenue notes for affordable housing projects at 735 Davis Street and 88 Broadway.

The Board approved resolutions related to financing for two affordable housing projects. These included loan agreements and multifamily housing revenue notes for projects at 735 Davis Street and 88 Broadway. All resolutions were adopted unanimously.

New Business

Authorized grant applications for the No Place Like Home Program for housing for persons with serious mental illness.

The Board approved resolutions authorizing the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development to apply for county noncompetitive and competitive allocation awards under the California Department of Housing and Community Development No Place Like Home Program.

New Business

Approved grants for HIV prevention and vocational rehabilitation services.

The Board approved resolutions retroactively authorizing the San Francisco Department of Public Health to accept and expend a grant from the California Department of Public Health to participate in the HIV Prevention State Grant program. Additionally, the Board approved a resolution authorizing the Department of Public Health to accept and expend a grant from the California Department of Rehabilitation to participate in the State Vocational Rehabilitation Services Program.

New Business

Approved an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to establish the Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee.

The Board approved an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to establish the Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee as an advisory committee to monitor the City’s use of tax revenue received under the Homelessness Gross Receipts Tax established by Proposition C.

New Business

Approved the donation of a retired ambulance to the San Francisco Unified School District.

The Board approved a resolution authorizing the Fire Department to donate a retired ambulance to the San Francisco Unified School District’s Health Academy at John O’Connell High School.

New Business

Approved an ordinance ordering the summary street vacation of portions of Bradford Street and Ogden and Crescent Avenues.

The Board approved an ordinance ordering the summary street vacation of portions of Bradford Street, Ogden Avenue, and Crescent Avenue within the perimeter of the Alemany Farmers’ Market. The ordinance also approved jurisdictional transfers of property at the site of the Market.

New Business

Approved an ordinance amending the Building Code to require vacant or abandoned commercial storefront owners to pay annual registration fees.

The Board approved an ordinance amending the Building Code to require vacant or abandoned commercial storefront owners to pay annual registration fees, require annual inspections of registered vacant or abandoned storefronts, and update the penalty for violations of the requirement to register vacant or abandoned commercial storefronts.

New Business

Approved an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to expand eligibility for assistance under various programs to adults ineligible for CalWORKs.

The Board approved an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to expand eligibility for assistance under the Personal Assistance Employment Services (PAES) Program, the Cash Assistance Linked to Medi-Cal (CALM) Program, and the Supplemental Security Income Pending (SSIP) Program, to adults who are ineligible for assistance under the CalWORKs Program.

New Business

Approved appointments to the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee and Assessment Appeals Boards.

The Board approved motions appointing Vanessa Bohm, John Maa, Joi Jackson-Morgan, Roberto Ariel Vargas, Johnathan Butler, Janna Cordeiro and Derik Aoki to the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee. Also, approved appointments and reappointments to Assessment Appeals Boards No. 1, 2, and 3.

New Business

Approved reappointments to the Park, Recreation, and Open Space Advisory Committee, and appointments to the Bicycle Advisory Committee and Police Commission.

The Board approved motions reappointing Wendy Aragon to the Park, Recreation and Open Space Advisory Committee. In addition, Kristin Tieche and Elbert Hill were appointed to the Bicycle Advisory Committee, and Cindy Elias was reappointed to the Police Commission.

Remarks

Recognized first responders and community members who assisted during and after the Geary Boulevard gas line explosion.

The Board suspended the rules to grant privilege of the floor to several guests. Supervisor Stefani introduced and presented a Certificate of Honor to first responders and community members who assisted during and after the Geary Boulevard gas line explosion in February 2019. Supervisor Fewer shared in this commendation. Chief Hayes-White provided additional commending remarks and acknowledgements. Also, Supervisor Mandelman presented a Certificate of Honor to the Castro Art Walk.

Hearing

Heard and filed an appeal of Tentative Map Approval for 630 Natoma Street, which was withdrawn by the appellant.

The Board opened a public hearing regarding an appeal of a Tentative Map Approval for a three-unit condominium project at 630 Natoma Street. Supervisor Haney provided opening remarks and the President inquired whether any individual wished to address the Board. With the appeal withdrawn, Supervisor Haney then moved to approve the Tentative Map. A speaker spoke in support of the project and in opposition to the appeal. The board then heard and filed the hearing.

New Business

Approved the Tentative Map for 630 Natoma Street after the appeal was withdrawn.

The Board approved the decision of Public Works and approved the Tentative Map for a three-unit condominium project at 630 Natoma Street after the appeal was withdrawn. The associated motions to conditionally disapprove and to prepare findings related to the Tentative Map were tabled.

Hearing

Heard and filed an appeal of a determination of exemption from environmental review for 2831-2833 Pierce Street.

The Board opened a public hearing regarding an appeal of a determination of exemption from environmental review for the proposed project at 2831-2833 Pierce Street. Genevieve Anderson (Appellant) provided an overview of the appeal. Stephanie Cisneros and Debra Dweyer (Planning Department) provided an overview of the decision of the Planning Department. Tara Sullivan, Reuben, Junius & Rose LLP (on behalf of Project Sponsor), provided an overview of the project and the Board then heard and filed the hearing.

New Business

Affirmed the categorical exemption determination for 2831-2833 Pierce Street.

The Board affirmed the determination by the Planning Department that the proposed project at 2831-2833 Pierce Street is categorically exempt from further environmental review. The associated motions to conditionally reverse the determination and to prepare findings to reverse the determination were tabled.

Committee Reports

Approved an ordinance amending the General Plan to include 175 Golden Gate Avenue in the Downtown General Commercial District.

The Board considered a recommendation from the Land Use and Transportation Committee, passing on first reading an ordinance to revise Map 1 of the Downtown Area Plan to include 175 Golden Gate Avenue, Assessor's Parcel Block No. 0349, Lot No. 11, in the C-3-G (Downtown General Commercial District) area.

Committee Reports

Approved an ordinance amending the Planning Code and Zoning Map regarding 175 Golden Gate Avenue, with an amendment.

The Board considered a recommendation from the Land Use and Transportation Committee, to amend the Planning Code and Zoning Map to rezone the building at 175 Golden Gate Avenue (De Marillac Academy). This was approved on the first reading, along with an amendment which removed a section detailing what the Historic Preservation Commission adopted for findings, and instead adding "A Copy" to the findings.

Committee Reports

Approved mayoral reappointments to the Historic Preservation Commission.

The board reviewed and approved recommendations from the Rules Committee on motion, regarding the nominations of Richard Johns, Kate Black and Andrew Wolfram for reappointments to the Historic Preservation Commission. Each was unanimously approved.

Public Testimony

Received public comment on various issues, including residential density, the Presidential Administration’s changes to Title X Family Planning Program, and the Director for the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing.

The board opened floor for public comment and heard from Richard Hack, about residential density, from Cecile Castillo, regarding Title X family planning, and from Charles Pitts regarding Director of Homelessness. Katherine Howard and another speaker spoke fondly about Mary Anne Miller.

Closed Session

Continued a Closed Session regarding labor negotiations to March 12, 2019.

The board moved to continue a closed session from an earlier date to March 12, 2019, to convene with the mayor's office and department of human resources. The purpose was to consider labor union contract negotiations for city employees.

Committee of the Whole

Approved a resolution extending the time for Planning Commission review of Accessory Dwelling Units in new construction and approving Final Map 9359.

Without committee reference the board reviewed and approved resolutions related to retroactive extensions for planning review on accessory dwelling units. Also, the board moved to approve Final Map 9359 for a six residential unit condominium project located at 830 Broderick Street.

Committee of the Whole

Continued to the Board of Supervisors meeting of March 19, 2019 was a resolution supporting an Irish Famine Memorial.

Severed from the consent agenda was a resolution supporting a permanent memorial in San Francisco for victims and survivors of the Irish Famine. The board moved to approve the item with the change of the word "criminally" to "shamefully" with all approving. It was then immediately moved to continue the resolution to March 19, 2019.

Committee of the Whole

Approved California State Assembly Bill No. 1611 (Chiu) - Emergency Hospital Services, with an amendment.

After being severed from the consent agenda, the board approved a resolution supporting California State Assembly Bill No. 1611, an amendment which would extend consumer protections to privately insured patients at San Francisco General Hospital. The amendment included language asserting insurance companies bear the responsibilities for trauma care, and that continued deliberations and study would be conducted to fairly define "Reasonable Charges" in order to ease burden on taxpayers.

Committee of the Whole

Approved supporting a hearing for an initiative to save lives, and urging negotiations from Walgreens Boots Alliance Inc.

Severed from the consent agenda was a resolution supporting senate bill 281, and it was moved to continue that approval on March 12, 2019. It regarded prohibiting firearm and ammunition sales at the Cow Palace in Daly City. There was also a hearing urging good faith negotiations from Walgreens, and approving a closed session on Municipal Elections on April 2, 2019.

Legislation Introduced

Introduced various ordinances and resolutions, including those related to homelessness services, business tax regulations, and planning code amendments.

The board conducted a roll call for introductions to the record. Some of the proposed resolutions included contracting for homelessness services, streamling certain programs like those in the Administrative and Planning Codes, business and tax regulations for gift credits to combat homelessness, an ordinance for streamlining contracting of homelessness services, waiving the Banner fee, and a resolution for HIV Prevention. All of these were referred for committee review.